A reader asks:
Which asset class will have better returns over the next 10 years: stocks or bonds?
I was asked this question while on stage at the Bogleheads conference last week in Las Vegas.1
The general tone of the question coming from the audience was basically stock market returns have been so strong it can’t possibly last. Mean reversion has to come eventually…right?
Let’s start with the historical data because it’s important to have a baseline in these matters.
I looked at the rolling 10 year returns for the S&P 500 and 5 year Treasuries going back to 1926:
Stocks beat bonds in most 10 year periods but it’s not guaranteed. There have been times when bonds beat stocks over 10 years.
It happens.
Another way to look at this is to see how often stocks have beaten a 5% bogey, which is around the current level of government bond yields.2
This number was higher than I anticipated. Stocks earned more than 5% per year in 85% of all 10 year time frames:
That’s pretty good.
But the 15% of the time when it has been below 5% wasn’t much fun to live through as an investor.
You can also look beyond the frequency and look at the magnitude of performance of stocks versus bonds when they win.
Here’s a look at the outperformance of each asset class when they outperformed over 10 years:
When stocks outperform bonds the magnitude of the victory is much great than when bonds beat stocks.
I understand why so many investors are worried about the U.S. stock market.
The 10 year annual return for the S&P 500 through the end of October was more than 15% per year.
The 15 year annual return is also close to 15% annually. From the lows of the Great Financial Crisis in March 2009, the index is up nearly 17% per year. That’s almost 18 years of extraordinary gains.
This is a generational bull market. The hard part about handicapping generational bull markets is that they can last a lot longer than you think but also tend to be painful when they end.
So if I had to place a bet in Las Vegas on stocks or bonds winning over the next 10 years, I would pick stocks every time. The probabilities are in your favor.
The good news is that you don’t need to bet on one or the other.
If you’re worried about mean reversion in the stock market, there are plenty of other options available.
Bond have risks even with yields at 5% but there is a much bigger margin of safety for fixed income investors when interest rates are higher.
At the Bogleheads conference I was on stage with Bill Bernstein and we talked about the difference between betting at the casino and investing in the stock market over the long haul.
Bill made the point that when you own the market for the long-term you are the house because the odds are in your favor.
But sometimes even the house loses.
Stocks will probably beat bonds over the next decade but probably doesn’t mean all the time.
Owning bonds isn’t for everyone but fixed income can help when you lose a hand or two.
Dave Nadig joined us on an all-new Ask the Compound with me this week to discuss this question:
We also answered questions about leveraged ETFs, option income products, how tech took over the villain spot from finance, Trump accounts for your kids and more.
Further Reading:
How I Think About Investing in Bonds
1It was my first Bogleheads conference. It was a great group of people. I enjoyed myself.
2Bonds aren’t guaranteed to earn 5% per year but the starting yield is a good approximation of future returns.
