Will Rising Rates Hurt REIT Performance?

The prevailing wisdom on real estate investment trusts (REITs) is that they’ll be doomed once interest rates start to rise. Because of the way REITs are structured for tax purposes they have to pay out at least 90% of their taxable income in the form of dividends.

The thinking goes that higher interest rates will provide competition against the yields on REITs, making them less attractive. I’m never one to take rules of thumb at face value so let’s see how this theory worked in past rising rate environments.

The Wilshire REIT Index goes all the way back to 1979. Here’s how this index performed during prior rising interest rates environments:

REITs Rates

In four out of the six periods where rates went substantially higher, REITs were actually positive. And in three out of the four positive time frames they showed outstanding performance.

If REITs were sensitive to interest rate moves, you would also expect them to be highly correlated with bonds. This hasn’t been the case. From 1979 to mid-2014, the correlation between the Wilshire REIT Index and the Barclays Capital Aggregate Bond Index was 0.02, signifying no relationship in price movements in that time.

As I’ve pointed out before, these relationships are never static over the years as the market environment is constantly evolving so it makes sense to look at the change in correlations over time. Here’s the rolling 5 year correlation between REITs and bonds from the inception of the Wilshire Index:

REITs and Bonds

There are times when the two asset classes moved together in the past but there’s not much of a discernible pattern here. REITs are actually more strongly correlated with stocks. The S&P 500 has a correlation coefficient of 0.40 with REITs over the same time frame. But that relationship changes as well:

REITs and Stocks

These changing relationships between asset classes can make it difficult on investors, but for a diversified portfolio this is actually the kind of behavior you would like to see. For inclusion in a portfolio, a long-term investment should generally have an expected return above inflation and not move in lockstep with the other asset classes selected.

It would be a mistake to compare REITs and bonds simply because they’re both income-producing assets. REITs are much closer to stocks in terms of the risk-return profile. Here are the largest annual losses for the Wilshire Index: -39.2%, -23.4%, -17.6%, -17.0% and -6.6%. Interestingly enough, REITs have outperformed stocks and bonds since 1979:

REIT perf

There are a few caveats that apply here. There weren’t many REIT funds available during most of this performance history. Vanguard’s REIT fund wasn’t available until 1997.

Plus, the total market value of the REIT sector is fairly small compared to the entire stock market. While the total value of the commercial real estate market is roughly the same size as the U.S. stock market, it’s not easy to invest in the all of these properties. As of 2013 there were only about 200 REITs available to trade at a market value of over $700 billion.  But REITs actually make up about 2% of the S&P 500 so most investors probably have some exposure to them already.

REITs are up almost 15% this year so it’s possible they could be sold as investors look elsewhere for gains. There’s no guarantee that REITs will perform poorly if rates ever do have a sustained rise. It’s also likely that inflation will pick up as well, which would allow the management companies of the REITs to increase the rents on tenants. Even though the historical record during rising rate environments looks promising, investor preferences going forward are the only thing that matters, as always.

Subscribe to receive email updates and my monthly newsletter by clicking here.

Follow me on Twitter: @awealthofcs

Share Button

Did Bill Gross Tip The Pop Machine Over?

Thousands of investment professionals gathered at McCormick Place in Chicago earlier this summer for the annual Morningstar Conference. The room had a definitive buzz to it at lunch time. Bill Gross was the keynote lunch speaker and everyone was patiently waiting to see what he would have to say after stories, rumors and gossip swirled from the departure of his number two and supposed successor at PIMCO, Mohamed El-Erian. Continue reading

Share Button

Why Investment Advice Can Be So Confusing

It’s not simply the news or the data itself that makes things interesting when following the markets, but the discussion and reaction that they bring about from investors. Interpretation and perception become the most important element, especially since information is so easy to come by these days. Continue reading

Share Button

When Exotic Devices Create Exotic Problems

Vanity Fair has a fascinating article in the latest issue on airplane safety and how it affects pilot error. To make planes safer these days, engineers have designed automated systems that basically allow the planes to fly themselves. Continue reading

Share Button

Some Stocks Don’t Come Back

“If every stock you own is on the new high list, you’re a momentum guy. If every stock you own is on the new low list, you’re out of business.” – Leon Cooperman

Continue reading

Share Button

My Experience with CDOs & The Real Estate Bubble

In early 2006 I was in the market for a new job. A friend from college worked for one of the largest banks and asked if I’d like to interview for a spot in his group. Continue reading

Share Button

Would a Repeat of the 1987 Crash Really Be That Bad?

“The intelligent investor realizes that stocks become more risky, not less, as their prices rise, and less risky, not more, as their prices fall.” – Jason Zweig

Continue reading

Share Button

What is a Bubble?

“The term bubble should indicate a price that no reasonable future outcome can justify.” – Cliff Asness

Continue reading

Share Button

An Education From Guy Spier

“I’m trying to manage myself, not just my portfolio.” – Guy Spier

Continue reading

Share Button

Enduring Lessons From the Financial Crisis

S&P 500

When asked what people would learn from the financial crisis, GMO’s Jeremy Grantham replied: Continue reading

Share Button