For years now it felt like the only game in town was U.S. large cap growth stocks.
That’s changed somewhat in the past few years.
Growth stocks have still done fine, of course, what with the AI boom and all. But other areas of the market have come to life. Emerging markets have outperformed. International stocks have staged a comeback.
And this year there are other areas of the market that are beating the S&P 500.
It’s shaping up to be a strange year in the stock market.
Let’s take a look.1
This one is really surprising:
Value stocks are crushing growth stocks this year.
Stocks with lower valuations are finally winning. Maybe value isn’t dead after all.
Small cap value is also outperforming this year, both in the U.S. and in foreign stocks:
I’m not sure how many people would have assumed small cap value stocks would be winning in a year where hyperscalers are dominating the headlines and investor interest.
The S&P 493 continues to outperform the Mag 7 and overall market this year as well:
One of the reasons the S&P 493 is outperforming is because it’s not the sexy sectors outperforming this year:
Technology stocks are essentially in line with the market while energy, consumer staples, healthcare, materials and real estate are outperforming the S&P 500.
Duality Research plots the forward PE ratios for every S&P 500 sector on a weekly basis:
Tech stock valuations have been crashing. Consumer staples have seen valuations explode higher.
Investors either don’t believe in tech earnings going forward or they are so worried about a crash that they’re willing to pay up for more defensive names.2
Of course, things can change in a hurry in this market.
Look at the performance of the iShares Momentum ETF:
In the spring it was down almost 8% on the year.
A few months later this fund had a gain of almost 40%. Now it’s back down to a 5% year-to-date return following a drawdown of almost 25%.
That’s like a full market cycle in the span of 11 months.
Speaking of momentum stocks — South Korea and Taiwan have both experienced big moves to the upside and downside this year because they are so concentrated in the AI sector.
However, even though both stock markets are in the midst of bear markets at the moment, they still have the highest returns of the country ETFs this year:
Look at the dispersion between the winners and losers. It’s all over the map.
There are 13 countries with double-digit YTD returns and 7 countries with double-digit YTD losses. Also, 26 out of the 46 country ETFs listed here are currently in a double-digit drawdown from 52-week highs.
Despite all of the crazy headlines, some of the hyperscalers crashing, geopolitics and more, one of the strangest parts about the market this year is the fact that the S&P 500 hasn’t been all that volatile.
The worst peak-to-trough drawdown came in the spring when it was down 9%. Right now it’s a little more than 6% off the highs.
These losses are tame.
Things can and will get much worse at some point.
That’s what happens with risk assets sometimes.
And sometimes markets don’t act how you think they should.
Further Reading:
This is Why You Need a Plan
1Assume all numbers here are through the close on Monday.
2This also could have something to do with the fact that the tech sector is up 660% in the past 10 years versus gains of 137% for consumer staples.
