How to Preserve Capital During a Bear Market

A few weeks ago I took part in a webcast with MarketWatch on long-term investing that was partly spurred on by a post I wrote about my idea for a TV show about investing. MarketsWatch’s Victor Reklaitis ran the show while I was joined by Tim Strauts from Morningstar and Chuck Jaffe of MarketWatch to answer viewer questions.

Here’s one of the questions that I thought deserved a deeper dive:

What’s your advice for handling an awful year for stocks like 2008?

This may seem like a silly thing to think about now, but you don’t start planning for a bear market after it occurs. If you prepare yourself psychologically for any investment environment ahead of time it decreases the chances of blowing up your portfolio by making unforced errors at the wrong time.

Courtesy of Eric Nelson from Servo Wealth Management, here are the five most severe bear markets since the 1920s broken out by losses, recovery and total return from peak to peak:

Bear Mkts

A few observations on Nelson’s data:

  • You don’t need to get fancy with black swan disaster hedges. High quality intermediate-term bonds have been your best option for preserving capital during an economic disaster. They do their job as the portfolio anchor during periods of stress to give investors dry powder for rebalancing purposes to buy stocks on sale or for spending purposes so stocks don’t get sold after a crash has occurred.
  • Stocks can fall far and fast but also tend to recover very quickly. That’s why bailing out of stocks after they crash just compounds your problems if you held them through the crash in the first place.
  • Balance is the key to surviving these periodic crashes. The Balanced Asset Class Index which included large caps, small caps, value stocks and bonds fared much better than the all-stock options and outperformed the other options over the full cycle 4 out of 5 times.
  • Value and small cap stocks are great diversifiers and return enhancers as you can see from the All Stock Asset Class, but be prepared for large losses as well.

The biggest thing is to have a plan and stick with it (everyone says this but it’s true). You won’t know the exact reasons ahead of time as to why the market will fall, but understand that you will see a handful of market crashes over your lifetime.

There’s no way you can avoid risk in the financial markets if you hope to beat inflation over the long-term and earn a respectable return on your portfolio. Stocks outperform bonds over longer cycles, but bonds provide stability when you need it the most. Stocks wouldn’t offer a risk premium over bonds if they didn’t have these periodic large selloffs.

It’s also important to understand your ability and willingness to take risk. Allocate more money to less volatile investments if you can’t handle losses, but understand that you will likely have to save more to reach your financial goals if you carry a more risk averse portfolio.

And for those investors that are in or approaching retirement, don’t have money tied up in stocks that you’ll need to use for spending purposes within 5 years or so. It’s too much of a risk that stocks could take a hit right when you need to sell if you have an all-stock portfolio.

For most average investors, a good rule of thumb would be to never own more stocks in a bull market than you’re comfortable holding during a bear market.

There really are no easy answers to this question as every investor’s tolerance for risk and investment strategy is different. Investing really is a balancing act that’s full of trade-offs. There is a constant tug of war going on inside our brains between fear and greed depending on the market environment. We want to be able to sidestep losses in the markets and only participate in the gains but it’s impossible to to invest in stocks and not experience periodic losses.

Pick your poison and understand your emotional swings.

Watch the entire MarketWatch webcast here: How to make money in the long run

When bad things happen to good portfolios (Servo Wealth)



Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Full Disclosure: Nothing on this site should ever be considered to be advice, research or an invitation to buy or sell any securities, please see my Terms & Conditions page for a full disclaimer.

What's been said:

Discussions found on the web
  1. Marc Gordon commented on Sep 14

    Excellent advice. I would add an additional thought to “Allocate more money to less volatile investments if you can’t handle losses”, which is that once you have made an allocation to stocks that is appropriate for you, accept that you likely will at some point experience a roughly 50% loss in your stock portfolio and that during such periods NEVER sell in a down market!

    • Ben commented on Sep 15

      Good point. Even within that allocation you have to be ready for a crash of that magnitude.

  2. Gary commented on Sep 15

    I think Marc Gordon makes a good point and I agree. In the article there is the reference to “a good rule of thumb would be to never own more stocks in a bull market than you’re comfortable holding during a bear market.” I just don’t think that is realistic. The trend really is your friend and when things get shakey there are clues dropped. I usually take a little off the table (particularly any under performers) but not anything too severe until/unless certain key points are breached. Even at that point I have never sold everything and have been better off for that, as the market does come back (even after 2008). I think using a 50% decline is unrealistic (exception an outside geopolitical catastrophe), but I think that a real correction (10-20%), could happen any time.

    • Ben commented on Sep 15

      Right, a huge crash is more of a 2-3 times in your lifetime while a 10-20% correction will probably happen every 2 years or so on average.

  3. Monday Morning Links | commented on Sep 15

    […] – MarketWatch Record S&P 500 Masks 47% of Nasdaq Mired in Bear Market – Bloomberg How to Preserve Capital During a Bear Market – Wealth of Common Sense What You Need to Know about Next Week’s 3 Key Events – […]

  4. Sentiment | Prudent Trader commented on Sep 15

    […] IOT AS THE THIRD WAVE OF THE INTERNET (Goldman Sachs) How to Preserve Capital During a Bear Market (Wealth of Common Sense) Carol J. Loomis: The Fortune legend & Buffett biographer talks about 60 years in business […]

  5. 10 Tuesday PM Reads | The Big Picture commented on Sep 16

    […] (WSJ) • Crash Ahead!!! (Above the Market) see also Preserving Capital During a Bear Market (Wealth of Common Sense) • Can Real Estate Stocks Cope with Rising Rates? (Context) • Ayn Rand’s Capitalist […]

  6. 10 Tuesday PM Reads | FAN FICTION PLANET commented on Sep 16

    […] (WSJ) • Crash Ahead!!! (Above the Market) see also Preserving Capital During a Bear Market (Wealth of Common Sense) • Can Real Estate Stocks Cope with Rising Rates? (Context) • Ayn Rand’s Capitalist […]